Pagan actions vs some Islamic rituals do they mean same?

Q: Can you please help in responding to this question
“Exalting stones by circling around them, touching them, and kissing them
The belief in holy water, drinking it, seeking blessings through it, and using it for healing
All of this is characteristic of distorting religion and deviating from what God revealed
God’s religion does not exalt stones, nor does it have holy water
All of this is part of Hinduism
(Pradakshina) Pradakshina is circling around the temple
The water of the Ganges River”

Response:

This claim conflates outward, superficial physical actions with the underlying theology, intention, and divine commands that define monotheism (Tawhid) versus idolatry (Shirk).

The rituals of Islam—such as circumambulating the Kaaba (Tawaf), kissing the Black Stone (al-Hajar al-Aswad), and drinking Zamzam water—differ fundamentally in nature, purpose, and theology from paganism and Hinduism [1][2][3][4].

1. Tawaf (Circumambulation) is Worship of Allah Alone, Not the Building

In pagan traditions (such as the Pradakshina around temple shrines), circumambulation is performed around deities or shrines believed to house divine spirits. In Islam, Tawaf is fundamentally different:

  • Dedicated to the Lord, not the structure: Muslims do not worship the Kaaba, its walls, or its stones. It serves as the unified direction (Qiblah) for prayer and a place of worship dedicated exclusively to the Creator [5][6][3]. Allah commanded: ﴿فَلْيَعْبُدُوا رَبَّ هَٰذَا الْبَيْتِ﴾ “So let them worship the Lord of this House.” [6]
  • Established on Pure Monotheism: The Kaaba was built by the Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) and his son Ismail (Ishmael) specifically to establish monotheism and eradicate idolatry [1][7]: ﴿وَإِذْ بَوَّأْنَا لِإِبْرَاهِيمَ مَكَانَ الْبَيْتِ أَن لَّا تُشْرِكْ بِي شَيْئًا وَطَهِّرْ بَيْتِيَ لِلطَّائِفِينَ وَالْقَائِمِينَ وَالرُّكَّعِ السُّجُودِ﴾ “And [mention] when We designated for Abraham the site of the House, [saying], ‘Do not associate anything with Me and purify My House for those who perform Tawaf and those who stand [in prayer] and those who bow and prostrate.’” [8]
  • Performance based on Divine Command: Tawaf is an act of pure obedience (ta’abbud) enacted to establish the remembrance and praise of Allah [2][8]: ﴿ثُمَّ لْيَقْضُوا تَفَثَهُمْ وَلْيُوفُوا نُذُورَهُمْ وَلْيَطَّوَّفُوا بِالْبَيْتِ الْعَتِيقِ﴾ “Then let them complete their prescribed duties and perform their vows and circumambulate the Ancient House.” [8][6]

2. The Black Stone: A Sign of Obedience, Not an Object of Devotion

Muslims do not attribute any divine essence, consciousness, or independent power to the Black Stone. It marks the designated point to begin and end the Tawaf [9][10].

  • Explicit Rejection of Superstition: When the companion Umar ibn al-Khattab kissed the Black Stone, he publicly clarified this core belief to ensure no one confused it with paganism [11][12][13]: «إِنِّي لأَعْلَمُ أَنَّكَ حَجَرٌ لا تَضُرُّ وَلا تَنْفَعُ، وَلَوْلا أَنِّي رَأَيْتُ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ﷺ يُقَبِّلُكَ مَا قَبَّلْتُكَ» “I know that you are only a stone that can neither harm nor benefit. Had I not seen the Messenger of Allah ﷺ kiss you, I would not have kissed you.” [11][14][15][16]
  • Absence of Idolatrous Mechanics: In idolatry, physical contact with an idol is believed to transmit magical or divine grace. In Islam, if one cannot reach the Stone due to crowds, simply pointing at it from a distance with a gesture and reciting the Takbir (magnifying God) fulfills the sunnah entirely [11][17][18].
  • Submission, Not Material Exaltation: The rites of Hajj demonstrate that stones hold no inherent sanctity: Muslims kiss the Black Stone in obedience to God, and they throw pebbles at the Pillars (Jamarat) in obedience to God [2][5][19]. The essence of the act is not stone-reverence, but submission to divine instruction [5][20][19].

3. Zamzam Water vs. Deified Rivers

The veneration of sacred waters in polytheism (such as the Ganges in Hinduism) involves believing the river is an incarnate goddess (Ganga) with independent spiritual powers to forgive sins.

In Islam:

  • A Created Blessing and Means: Zamzam is purely a physical creation of Allah, provided miraculously as a spring to sustain Hajar and the infant Ismail in the barren desert of Mecca [21][22][23].
  • Healing by God’s Permission: Drinking Zamzam is a blessed act because the Prophet ﷺ described it as nourishing and beneficial by God’s decree, functioning as a means (sabab) rather than an independent deity [24][22][25]: «إِنَّهَا مُبَارَكَةٌ، إِنَّهَا طَعَامُ طُعْمٍ، وَشِفَاءُ سُقْمٍ» “It is blessed; it is food that satisfies and a cure for illness.” [21][26][27]
  • Any healing or blessing derived from Zamzam is sought directly from Allah through supplication, not from the water itself [28][29][30].

4. Outward Form vs. Inward Reality

Superficial similarities in human physical actions (such as walking in circles, washing with water, or standing in rows) exist across various cultures and religions. However, the defining boundary between Monotheism (Tawhid) and Idolatry (Shirk) lies in:

  1. The Object of Worship: Islam directs all prayers, vows, sacrifices, and ultimate devotion exclusively to the One Unseen God, rejecting all intermediaries [16][3][31].
  2. The Source of Authority: Muslims perform these specific actions solely because God commanded them through His revealed messengers, not because of superstitions regarding the material objects themselves [2][3][4].

Sources:
[1] Durus li al-Shaykh Muhammad al-Mukhtar al-Shinqiti — vol. 42, p. 8
[2] Majmu Fatawa wa Rasail al-Uthaymin — vol. 2, p. 318
[3] Raf al-Ishtibah an Mana al-Ibada wal-Ilah – ضمن Athar al-Muallimi — vol. 3, p. 830
[4] Tafsir Surat al-Fatiha – ضمن “Athar al-Muallimi — vol. 7, p. 101
[5] Silsilat Mahasin al-Tawil – al-Maghamsi — vol. 4, p. 14
[6] Fatawa al-Shaykh Ibn Jibreen — vol. 60, p. 39
[7] Sharh Bulugh al-Maram li Atiyya Salim — vol. 77, p. 5
[8] al-Mawsua al-Fiqhiyya — vol. 2, p. 172
[9] Mawqi al-Islam Su’al wa Jawab — vol. 1, p. 837
[10] al-Qawl al-Mubin fi Sirat Sayyid al-Mursalin — vol. 1, p. 43
[11] Al-Ifham fi Sharh Umdat al-Ahkam — vol. 1, p. 474
[12] al-Qawaid fi Tawhid al-Ibada — vol. 1, p. 261
[13] Juhud Ulama al-Hanafiyya fi Ibtal Aqaid al-Quburiyya — vol. 2, p. 657
[14] al-Badr al-Munir fi Takhrij al-Ahadith wal-Athar al-Waqia fi al-Sharh al-Kabir — vol. 6, p. 191
[15] al-Tawdih li Sharh al-Jami al-Sahih — vol. 11, p. 351
[16] Fatawa wa Istisharat al-Islam al-Yawm — vol. 5, p. 324
[17] Sharh Bulugh al-Maram – al-Luhaymid — vol. 2, p. 401
[18] Sharh Sunan Abi Dawud lil-Ubbad — vol. 220, p. 27
[19] Tafsir al-Shaarawi — vol. 3, p. 1637
[20] Taysir al-Allam Sharh Umdat al-Ahkam — vol. 1, p. 393
[21] Zad al-Maad fi Hady Khayr al-Ibad — vol. 4, p. 582
[22] Durus li al-Shaykh Muhammad al-Munajjid — vol. 189, p. 8
[23] al-Rukn al-Khamis — vol. 1, p. 502
[24] al-Sira al-Nabawiyya fi Daw al-Quran wa al-Sunna — vol. 1, p. 158
[25] Fatawa Tataallaq bi Ahkam al-Hajj wal-Umra wal-Ziyara — vol. 1, p. 139
[26] al-Siraj al-Munir fi Tartib Ahadith Sahih al-Jami al-Saghir — vol. 1, p. 403
[27] Majmu Fatawa wa Maqalat Mutanawwia – Ibn Baz — vol. 17, p. 229
[28] Nihayat al-Arab fi Funun al-Adab — vol. 1, p. 317
[29] al-Durr al-Manthur fi al-Tafsir bi al-Mathur — vol. 4, p. 151
[30] Muthir al-Gharam al-Sakin ila Ashraf al-Amakin — vol. 1, p. 321
[31] Mawsuat Mahasin al-Islam wa Radd Shubuhat al-Liam — vol. 6, p. 183

https://qaf.ai/s/52ad5eb7-37eb-48c1-af94-189e4ba24e7d

Leave a Reply