Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic

Bombings of 1945

Nov 14, 2026 ·

@zsyed52@hotmail.com

Introduction

Islamic law does not permit ending a war by deliberately destroying cities full of non-

combatants, and the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki f all outside what

classical jurists allowed. This piece makes that case from the Qur’an, the Sunnah and the

fiqh tradition, including the hard texts critics raise, and then examines the history of

August 1945 as historians actually debate it.

The aim is an argument that holds up against informed objection from both Muslim and

non-Muslim readers. Where the evidence is contested, this piece says so.

Islamic law on non-combatants

Deliberately targeting women, children and other non-combatants is prohibited by

explicit Prophetic command, and the jurists agree on this. Incidental harm in legitimate

combat was discussed separately , under strict limits.

The core prohibition

The Qur’an limits fighting to those who fight and forbids transgression:

وَﻗَاﺗ ِ ﻠُوا ﻓِي ﺳَﺒ ِ يﻞِ الﻠﻪِ اﻟﺬِيﻦَ ﻳ ُ ﻘَاﺗ ِ ﻠُوﻧ َ ﻜ ُ ﻢْ وَﻻ َ ﺗ َ ﻌْﺘ َ ﺪُوا ۚ إ ِ ن الﻠﻪَ ﻻ َ ﻳ ُ ﺤِﺐ  اﻟْﻤُﻌْﺘ َ ﺪِيﻦَ

“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you, but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah

does not love transgressors.

” (al-Baqarah 2:190)

Ibn ‘Umar reported that a woman was found killed in one of the Prophet’s ﷺ campaigns,

and he forbade the killing of women and children (al-Bukhari 3015; Muslim 17 44). In the

instructions he gave to commanders, he said: «وَﻻ َ ﺗ َ ﻘْﺘ ُ ﻠُوا وَﻟِيﺪًا» “and do not kill a child”

(Muslim 1731, from Buraydah).

Abu Bakr’s instructions to Y azid ibn Abi Sufyan forbade killing women, children and the

elderly , cutting fruit-bearing trees, and «وَﻻ َ ﺗ ُ ﺨَﺮﺑ َ ﻦ ﻋَاﻣِﺮًا» “do not lay waste an inhabited

place” (Muwatta’ Malik, Kitab al-Jihad). Its chain is mursal, but jurists widely relied on it.

Page 1 of 6Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Its ban on ruining inhabited places bears directly on the destruction of whole cities.

Qur’an 5:32 is often quoted here. It was addressed in context to the Children of Israel, but

scholars commonly cite it as a universal statement of the sanctity of life, and it can be

used that way with that note.

The hard cases critics will raise

An honest argument must address three texts:

Night raids. Asked about women and children struck in night attacks on polytheists,

the Prophet ﷺ said « ْﻫُﻢْ ﻣِﻨ ْ ﻬُﻢ» “they are from them” (al-Bukhari 3012; Muslim 17 45, from

al-Sa’b ibn Jaththama). Jurists such as al-Nawawi read this as covering unintended

harm when combatants and non-combatants cannot be separated, not as permission

to target non-combatants.

The mangonel at T a’if . Sira sources report a catapult used during the siege of T a’if (8

AH). The reports’ chains are debated, and the event involved a fortified city defended

by fighters.

Human shields (tatarrus). Jurists discussed when attacking enemy fighters who

shelter among non-combatants or captives is allowed, generally only under real

necessity and with the duty to aim at fighters.

In each case the permission concerns incidental harm while targeting combatants. A

weapon chosen precisely because it destroys an entire city and most of its inhabitants is

different in kind. Many contemporary scholars hold that weapons of mass destruction

used against population centres f all outside any of these allowances.

Prophetic models of restraint

T wice the Prophet ﷺ held the stronger position and chose terms that spared lives over a

crushing victory .

Hudaybiyyah (6 AH)

At Hudaybiyyah the Prophet ﷺ accepted terms his companions found humiliating. He

agreed to drop “Bismillah al-Rahman al-Rahim” and “Messenger of Allah” from the

document, to return to Madinah without performing ‘umrah that year , and to send back

those who came over from Quraysh. He gave way on wording and procedure to avoid

fighting at the Haram. The Qur’an then called the treaty a clear victory (al-F ath 48:1).

Page 2 of 6Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

The conquest of Mecca (8 AH)

The Prophet ﷺ entered Mecca with overwhelming force after two decades of

persecution and war . He announced security for whoever entered Abu Sufyan’s house,

laid down arms, or closed his door (Muslim 1780). The city was taken with very little

bloodshed, and the general population was spared.

The widely quoted words «ُاذْﻫَﺒ ُ وا ﻓَﺄ َ ﻧ ْ ﺘ ُ ﻢُ الﻄﻠَﻘَاء» “Go, you are free” come through sira reports

whose chain several hadith scholars, including al-Albani, grade as weak. It is safer to cite

the amnesty through Muslim’s narration. Honesty also requires noting that a small

number of named individuals were excluded from the amnesty for specific crimes.

What happened in 1945

Japan surrendered within days of two atomic bombings and the Soviet declaration of war ,

after its leaders had resisted surrender for months. Deaths by the end of 1945 are

estimated at about 90,000–140,000 in Hiroshima and 40,000–70,000 in Nagasaki,

overwhelmingly civilians. These figures are approximate and vary by source.

Date (1945) Event

9–10 March 11 June 16 June July 26 July 6 August 8 August US firebombing of T okyo kills an estimated 80,000–

100,000 people, mostly civilians

Franck Report: some Manhattan Project scientists

urge a demonstration on an uninhabited area

instead of use on a city

The project’s Scientific P anel advises that no

demonstration would likely end the war

Japan asks the Soviet Union to mediate, without

stating concrete terms; the US reads the cables

through intercepts

Potsdam Declaration demands unconditional

surrender of Japan’s armed forces; it says nothing

about the Emperor

Atomic bomb on Hiroshima

Soviet Union declares war on Japan and invades

Manchuria

Page 3 of 6Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Date (1945) Event

9 August 10 August 11 August 14–15 August 2 September Atomic bomb on Nagasaki

Japan offers to accept Potsdam on condition the

Emperor’s prerogatives are preserved

US reply (Byrnes Note): the Emperor will be

subject to the Allied Supreme Commander

Army officers attempt a coup to stop the

surrender; it f ails, and the Emperor’s surrender

broadcast airs on 15 August

Formal surrender aboard USS Missouri; the

Emperor keeps his throne

W ere there alternatives?

Historians still disagree on whether Japan would have surrendered soon without the

bombs. Several alternatives were raised at the time, and each carried real uncertainty or

its own cost in civilian lives.

Alternative Strongest case for it Main difficulty

Clarify that the Emperor

could stay

Pursue Soviet mediation Demonstrate the bomb on

an uninhabited site

The US let the Emperor

remain after surrender

anyway; several US officials

urged saying so before

Potsdam

Japan was actively seeking a

negotiated exit in July

Proposed by the Franck

Report scientists; would

have spared civilians

Japan’s war cabinet also

wanted no occupation, its

own disarmament and its own

war-crimes trials, and stayed

deadlocked even after both

bombs

The Soviets had already

promised at Y alta to enter the

war and were not neutral;

T okyo never stated concrete

terms

The Scientific P anel feared a

f ailed or unconvincing test,

and the US had only two

bombs ready

Page 4 of 6Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Alternative 

Strongest case for it 

Main difficulty

W ait for the Soviet entry to

take effect

Some historians, notably

T suyoshi Hasegawa, argue

the Soviet invasion shocked

T okyo as much as the bombs

Timing and outcome are

uncertain; Japan’s military

still aimed for one decisive

battle

Continue blockade and

bombing

Japan was cut off from oil

and food; its navy and air

force were largely

destroyed

Starvation would have killed

very large numbers of

civilians; conventional

bombing was already killing

tens of thousands

The last row matters for the Islamic argument. A blockade that starves a nation into

surrender also f alls hardest on non-combatants, so it is not a clean alternative by the

standards set out above. The stronger claim is narrower: diplomatic options, especially

clarifying the Emperor’s status, were available and were not seriously tried before cities

were destroyed.

Defenders of the decision, such as historian Richard Frank, argue Japan’s leaders were

preparing to fight on and that an invasion would have cost f ar more lives on both sides.

That case should be acknowledged and answered, not ignored.

Conclusion

The Islamic case against the atomic bombings does not depend on proving that Japan

would have surrendered anyway . It rests on the means: Islamic law forbids deliberately

targeting non-combatants, and destroying entire cities to break a nation’s will is

deliberate targeting by design.

The Prophet’s ﷺ conduct at Hudaybiyyah and Mecca shows that patience, concession on

terms, and mercy from a position of strength are part of the Islamic ethic of war . Victory is

judged by how it is won, not only by whether it ends the fighting.

The history remains debated, and an honest presentation says so. Acknowledging the

hard texts and the counterarguments makes the conclusion more persuasive, not less.

Page 5 of 6Ending a War: Islamic Ethics and the Atomic Bombings of 1945

Sources and verification notes

Hadith numbers follow the standard Fu’ad ‘ Abd al-Baqi numbering for Muslim and the

common F ath al-Bari numbering for al-Bukhari; check them against your edition before

publishing. Casualty figures and dates were written from general knowledge without a

live lookup and are approximate.

Islamic sources

Qur’an: al-Baqarah 2:190; al-Ma’idah 5:32; al-F ath 48:1

Sahih al-Bukhari 3012, 3015

Sahih Muslim 1731, 17 44, 17 45, 1780

Muwatta’ Malik, Kitab al-Jihad: Abu Bakr’s instructions to Y azid ibn Abi Sufyan

al-Nawawi, Sharh Sahih Muslim, on hadith 17 45

From the original draft (verify each reference before use)

F atawa Dar al-Ifta’ al-Misriyya, vol. 10, p. 415

Majallat al-Risala, issue 416, p. 9

Mawsu’at al-Ghazawat al-Kubra, vol. 5, p. 287 and vol. 7, p. 88

Mawsu’at Mahasin al-Islam wa Radd Shubuhat al-Li’am, vol. 3, p. 418

al-A ‘mal al-Kamila lil-Imam Muhammad al-Khidr Husayn, vol. 10/1, p. 32

Mawsu’at al-Ijma’ fi al-Fiqh al-Islami, vol. 6, p. 114

Maqalat Mawqi’ al-Durar al-Saniyya, vol. 3, pp. 428–429

al-Siyasa al-Shar’iyya (al-Jami’a al-Islamiyya bil-Madina), vol. 1, p. 792

Historical sources (differing views)

T suyoshi Hasegawa, Racing the Enemy (2005): stresses the Soviet entry

Richard B. Frank, Downfall (1999): defends the decision as ending the war

J. Samuel W alker , Prompt and Utter Destruction (3rd ed., 2016): a balanced survey

Gar Alperovitz, The Decision to Use the Atomic Bomb (1995): argues the bombs were

unnecessary

Page 6 of 6

Leave a Reply